[Those of you who have minimal interest in technology, consider yourselves warned. And yes, I know. GYOB.]
Tim Bray points to something about the hardware-and-media side of Digital Rights Management, better known as the reason why you can't copy a DVD to VHS (among many annoyances). One of the guys to whom Tim links then begs for a soundbite, and I'm happy to oblige.
It's simple. The entertainment conglomos are charging consumers the same price for less product, treating adults like children, and eviscerating popular culture.
Used to be, if I had a film, TV show, or LP, then I could transfer it to another medium without difficulty. That's no longer true, yet in most cases (with films being the notable exception) I pay just as much as (if not more than) I'd paid in the past, except that my fair-use rights have been suspended.
This misstep is far worse than exchanging less value for the same price. I am not a thief, but the presence of DRM in your product makes clear the assumption that I am. Fuck you, and the horse you rode in on. Since I must be a thief, I will gleefully live up to your expectations when the need or desire presents itself (which is to say, rarely).
Particularly good creative works get lodged in the culture and the common discourse. Orwell's predictions made in 1984 inform everyone's understanding of State surveillance, Gone With the Wind serves as a common metaphor for both tempestuous relationships and the antebellum South, and the songs of popular hip-hop artists serve as an antidote to the anxiety of those who feel they've been left without real choices... to point out just three examples.
However, since all of those works are (in the United States at least) locked up under a seemingly perpetual copyright, every attempt to leverage their value to the culture of the English-speaking world must be adjudicated with regard to the potential for profit.
...The hell?
Can someone please explain to me what's good about DRM? And please don't try to tell me that it protects the rights of artists as a class - the closer they get to the Long Tail, the more they are already this fucked.